Management Academy · Research case study · 2024

Process Improvement — MAD Imbottiti Planning

An analysis of upholstered furniture production planning: how to structure the process for bespoke orders, reduce rework and preserve the value of craftsmanship.

Poltrona imbottita MAD, esempio di prodotto artigianale
AuthorKatherine Maloney
ProgrammeExecutive Master · Management Academy
Presentation29 October 2024 · Milan
Case studyMAD Imbottiti · Mariano Comense
01 / Context

Craftsmanship meets the complexity of production planning.

MAD Imbottiti is a luxury upholstered furniture manufacturer in Brianza, Italy. Production includes standard items and bespoke projects, organised as a job shop.

The analysis examines a production environment in which each product requires careful consideration of materials, operator skills, manufacturing stages and aesthetic requirements. Craft quality remains essential.

Spazio produttivo MAD Imbottiti
Production setting documented in the presentation, slide 4.
18

people in the production organisation described

3

main areas: cutting, sewing, assembly

70%

share of standard products in the analysis

30%

share of bespoke products in the analysis

RESEARCH / COMPANY AND PRODUCTION

MAD Imbottiti: company, market and production model.

More than 70 years of tradition

Luxury furniture manufacturer in Mariano Comense, Brianza, a region closely linked to skilled craftsmanship. Partner to major Italian furniture names.

International group

Part of the Roda Group. The presentation mentions production and commercial operations in Bangkok, Thailand, North America and Canada, with cooperation among managers across locations.

Products and customers

Armchairs, sofas, chairs, poufs, beds and outdoor furniture for restaurants, hotels, lounge bars, venues and luxury homes.

Job shop

Work is planned across three processing islands. 18 people: cutting 3, sewing 7, assembly 6, planning and supply chain 2.

Craftsperson at the centre

Processing time varies by product, materials and the operator's technical skills. The company culture stresses close cooperation with craftspeople.

Sales mix

70% standard products, 30% custom products. Custom quotations are especially challenging because jobs differ from one another.

PROJECT PURPOSE · THESIS

Project purpose

Meet committed delivery dates and initial budgets without unnecessarily extending production time, while preserving the quality of bespoke upholstered furniture.

On-time delivery

Improve planning and assembly so that completed products are delivered on schedule.

Cost control

Avoid repeated work that increases labour, energy and materials expenditure.

Customer-supplied components

Coordinate the provision of frames, bases, fabric and collection transport by the customer or project manager.

Quality and efficiency

Combine artisan craft standards with an efficient, productive organisational process.

Continuous improvement

Apply Kaizen to repeatable products; the presentation cites a ten-month improvement journey for a standard item.

Time and methods

MAD measures processing times and methods used in production.

QUALITY & POSITIONING

Strategic objectives

Deliver a “perfect” product for the luxury-furniture market. The thesis mentions an average price of approximately €4,000 for an armchair as context for the exacting quality expectations.

Functional quality

The furniture must fulfil its intended function.

Formal and aesthetic quality

Symmetry and clean lines are essential.

Fine finishing

Stitching should be continuous, accurate and free from loose threads.

Premium materials

Fabric and finishes must be first-class.

Flexible production

Respond to varying products, materials and craft skills without compromising standards.

02 / The challenge

The know-how is there. But it does not always become shared knowledge.

For bespoke orders, the experience of craftspeople and the Supply Chain Manager is crucial. The study identifies problems when knowledge, past defects and design decisions remain largely in people’s memories.

ISSUE 01

Incomplete initial information

Imprecise photographs and drawings can make it harder to define the work and prepare reliable quotations.

ISSUE 02

Limited digitisation of experience

The history of orders, variations and defects is not organised in an easily accessible repository.

ISSUE 03

Late corrections

Involving craftspeople only once production starts can lead to revisions, rework and delays.

PROBLEM ANALYSIS / SLIDES 8–9

How rework arises in production.

Information and quotation

Custom jobs often start with a photograph of a similar piece and a description of the desired furniture. Small differences can affect quotations. The Supply Chain Manager studies the stages, relies on remembered precedents and produces the executive drawing.

Knowledge about past defects is handed down verbally, without an easily searchable digital order archive.

Problems discovered during production

In the described process, craftspeople are mainly involved during manufacturing. Late problems lead to process redesign or rework, including fabric changes.

These can increase energy, material, labour and delivery times. The thesis also notes limited use of prototypes and the opportunity to group bespoke items into similar product families.

03 / How it works

The process under review.

The order workflow differs for standard and bespoke products. The research primarily examines bespoke orders, for which design and quotation rely on case-specific assessments.

Current workflow · bespoke order
01 / OrderCustomer request
02 / DefinitionPhotos, drawings and description
03 / AssessmentReview of stages and recalled defects
04 / ProposalProcess and quotation
05 / AcceptanceCustomer confirmation
Editorial adaptation of the “Order Process for Jobs” diagram (slide 7). Standard products follow the catalogue route.
Planimetria originale delle isole produttive
Production layout: assembly, sewing and cutting · slide 5.
The organisation

Three operational areas, one integrated plan.

The thesis reports 3 employees in cutting, 7 in sewing, 6 in assembly and 2 in planning / supply chain management.

Operations vary by product, material and skill: this is why the initial analysis affects the ability to meet deadlines and budgets.

AS-IS · ORDER PROCESS

Order process for customer jobs

The presentation separates standard catalogue orders from bespoke orders requiring a tailored manufacturing process.

Original diagram from the thesis (Italian)

Processo degli Ordini per le Commesse — diagramma originale

Standard order

01
Customer order

The request is received.

02
Standard or bespoke?

Order classification.

03
Catalogue product

The standard article is identified.

04
Order confirmation

The order confirmation is prepared.

05
Customer acceptance

The customer approves the order.

Bespoke order

01
Customer order and initial references

Product drawing and photo of a similar product.

02
Process-stage analysis

Supply Chain Manager studies manufacturing stages.

03
Quality control input

Past defects are consulted through experience and mental recollection.

04
Tailored process design

Supply Chain Manager designs the manufacturing process.

05
Quotation and acceptance

Quotation is submitted to the customer for approval.

In the process studied, artisans typically become involved during production to resolve practical issues; this may require redesign and rework.

03A / Project scheduling

The order process Gantt chart.

A faithful reconstruction of the sequence illustrated in the presentation Gantt: nine activities across June and July 2024. The bars retain the positions shown in the original screenshot.

Task / stage
JUNE 2024JULY 2024
313456710111213141718192021242526272812345891011
01 Customer order
02 Custom order
03 Photo and drawing review
04 Process stage assessment
05 QC reviews previous defects
06 SCM redesigns production process
07 Past order database review
08 Quotation submitted to customer
09 Customer order acceptance
04 / Field evidence

From frame to finished product.

The presentation documents furniture production through photographs, from structural frames to successive upholstery and covering stages. Images are taken directly from the project slides.

Sedia imbottita artigianale
Focus / Standard e custom

Detail is part of the process.

Symmetry, clean lines, even stitching and quality finishes are key characteristics of the products studied. Planning must protect these requirements while managing timing, workloads and variations.

Real cases: delivery deviations

Data reproduced from the table on slide 13. These cases do not constitute an aggregate performance measurement.

OrderFinding reported in the analysisReported outcome
Inedito chairSmall photograph and insufficient detail; revisions to the item, fabric and stitching.6 weeks late
Bali cushionNo issues reported.On time
Pag sofas and chairsExtensive prototyping.On time
Pouf Meridiani — GinoStandard product optimised through 10 months of improvement.On time
Club House — Brook StreetBespoke product not previously manufactured.1 week late
Eclipse chairs — TurriMoved from bespoke to standard, supported by established production experience.1 week early
FIELD ANALYSIS · ORIGINAL ORDER DATA

Analysis of real cases

Complete transcription of the seven cases in the presentation, including planned and actual timing, causes, corrective actions and reported variances. Blank or ambiguous source fields remain marked as not specified.

Order / caseProduction startExpected deliveryTrigger / issueResponse / solutionActual deliveryVariance
Inedito chairWk 32Wk 36Small photo with insufficient detailItem reworked with changed fabric and stitchingWk 426 weeks late
Bali cushionWk 36Wk 39NoneNot indicatedWk 39On time
Pag sofas and chairsWk 6Wk 43NoneExtensive prototypingWk 43On time
Meridiani – Gino pouf7/8, wk 32Wk 41NoneStandard product optimised over 10 months; assembly only11 Oct, wk 41On time
Club House – Brook Street (RL)2 Sep, wk 36Wk 42Not specifiedPreviously unproduced bespoke product17 Oct, wk 42/431 week late
Eclipse chairs – Turri (OC444)6 Aug, wk 3217 Oct, wk 42Not specifiedBespoke-to-standard transition; Turri prototype; 4 years of production experience11 Oct, wk 411 week early
Int. MarketQuote Feb 2024; drawing approval May 2024; materials 1 Oct30 Sep wk 40; 30 Oct wk 44Materials not supplied for all units; frame modificationsNot indicatedNot indicatedNot planned / unquantified

Weeks, dates and entries are retained as reported in the original material; “Int. Market” contains incomplete/ambiguous entries and is not treated as a measured delay.

PROJECT LIMITS

Constraints and critical issues

Just-in-time components

The customer must supply the necessary elements in time for the production schedule.

More design effort up front

A moderate increase in early planning work may be needed to prevent later rework.

Limited reuse of unique designs

Brand-new bespoke projects cannot always be repeated or standardised.

Artisan expertise

The improvement must protect and involve the know-how of skilled craftspeople.

Luxury workmanship

The customer expects exceptionally accurate finishing and an item made to the highest standard.

Cost of rework

Revisions during manufacture can increase labour, energy and material consumption and delay deliveries.

05 / The proposal

Redesign the process before having to redesign the product.

The thesis proposes earlier analysis, digitised knowledge and the integration of craftspeople’s input during order preparation. The actions shown here are recommendations, not measured improvements.

01 / KNOWLEDGE

Reference database

Store similar products, orders, defects, variations and solutions to support future assessments.

02 / DESIGN

3D prototyping

Use prototypes and models, including scale models, to assess feasibility at an earlier stage.

03 / PEOPLE

Earlier craft involvement

Bring production expertise into process definition from the outset.

04 / INFORMATION

Standardised brief

Improve the quality of incoming information through clearer photographs, drawings and specifications.

05 / CONTINUOUS IMPROVEMENT

Kaizen

Build on experience from repeatable orders that can gradually be standardised.

06 / CONTROL

Focus on process time

Focus on controllable processing time, distinguishing it from factors outside production.

Current situation

Before

  1. Initial briefs with inconsistent images and detail
  2. Past issues reviewed from memory
  3. Craft involvement often begins during production
  4. Risk of rework and additional time
Proposed process

After · target model

  1. Better structured initial briefs and information
  2. Consultation of a digitised project history
  3. Prototypes and craft input during design
  4. Database updated after each order
TO-BE · PROPOSED ORDER PROCESS

New order process for customer jobs

The proposed process preserves the standard catalogue route while strengthening the bespoke route with early artisan involvement, 3D prototyping and a shared order-history database.

Original diagram from the thesis (Italian)

Nuovo Processo degli Ordini per le Commesse — diagramma originale

Standard order · unchanged route

01
Customer order

Order is received.

02
Standard item

Catalogue item is identified.

03
Order confirmation

Confirmation is issued.

04
Customer acceptance

Customer approves the order.

Bespoke order · improved route

01
Initial brief

Collect product drawing and image of a similar product.

02
Process analysis

Supply Chain Manager studies the required stages.

03
Order database

Quality Control consults recorded historical defects and previous orders.

04
3D prototyping

Evaluate models or 3D-printed prototypes early.

05
Artisan proposals

Appropriate craftsperson contributes ideas to the production-process definition.

06
Process redesign

Supply Chain Manager develops the customised manufacturing plan.

07
Customer quotation

Present the proposal and quotation for acceptance.

08
Update history

Update the order database after the job for continuous improvement.

06 / Conclusions

Process improvement without losing the value of savoir-faire.

The project’s challenge is to introduce methods and transferable knowledge into luxury production without sacrificing product uniqueness and quality.

A question of balance

Investing more effort in design can be justified when it prevents errors, wasted materials and repeated work. The thesis also recognises constraints: timely customer-supplied inputs, the complexity of one-off products and variable production loads.

Qualitative research conclusion · no invented ROI or percentage improvement.

FINDINGS & RECOMMENDATIONS

Conclusions

Reference database

Document previous jobs, defects and solutions instead of relying only on memory.

3D model prototyping

Anticipate feasibility reviews with physical or digital models.

Early craftsperson involvement

Bring the right artisan into the design process as soon as possible.

Standardise initial information

Improve drawings, photos, specifications and early communication.

Kaizen

Keep improving and stabilising processes for recurring products.

Focus on process time

Measure and improve process time, the variable more directly under operational control.

These are recommendations from the research, not claims that a measured ROI or percentage reduction was achieved.